This is definitely a good face-off, wilder, between these two early thrash albums.
I really like both albums, no question. I remember initially being a bit turned off by Turbin's vocals, but I soon came around to liking it.
'Feel the Fire' is, arguably, one of Overkill's finest albums (and I'm not even an especially big fan of the band). For a debut, FtF is a cracking record to arrive as a band. But I honestly like Anthrax's FoM even more. I've been told by some Anthrax fans I've known that it's a 'grower', i.e. it took them a while to start to seriously dig the album. I liked FoM a whole lot, right from the get-go. And that's the way I voted here. Fistful of Metal, for me.